The Guild 3

.

A good improvement fromthe second one, yeah there are some bugs, but so as the former. Overall a better experience than the II, the comments are too harsh in my opinion

abandoned, still buggy and with broken economy

An abandoned game. Don't waste your time with this one.

It made me comment.

I prefer guild 2

its good, but i dont like it when ai cheats...

not worth it

Just play guild 2

nothing like screenshots or images shown. shell of a game

Really fun game. Not super replayable in single player do. REALLY fun multiplayer do.

give us the features from The Guild 2.

It's a good game ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

meow

I've enjoyed it despite the flaws.

The game is great, the devs should really come back

Last time there was an update was 1.5 years ago.

Sigh.

This game is good it is one of a kind, and I see that most bad reviews are all posted by people with out most 20 hours on record. If your going to write a geniune review about a game you must atleast have some hours on it for an honest experience. I personally enjoyed the game it is just a great idea made well.

Mixed reviews when I am posting this, and around 6,500 reviews. Many of the recent reviews are positive and talking about how it's a great game.

The most interesting thing to me, however, is how low the hours are on all of those positive reviews.

The game has 6,500 reviews, 61% are positive, and there are only 71 reviewers that liked the game enough to play it for 100+ hours.

Compare that to The Guild 2: Renaissance. The Guild 2: Renaissance is just one of a handful of stand alone Guild 2 games which didn't require the other versions to work.

Renaissance has a total of 3,200 reviews, half as many as TG3, likely due to presence of other purchasable versions all released around the same time. Renaissance has 81% positive reviews, and despite the lower number of reviews has 170 reviewers with over 100 hours played. That's about 5% of the reviewers playing it for 100+ hours compared to 1.1% for TG3.

Even though TG2 is buggy as heck, it was much more enjoyable than this souless sequel and the play time of reviewers is pretty enlightening.

golden oldie

I likey

A well designed and greatly refined dynasty builder with a plethora of options to develop your legacy. Still some minor hiccups here and there, but very easy to loss several hours at a time playing this game.

Full agreement with the reviews that state this just feels like no love went into it, and was abandoned. There has not been an update since 2023.

How can it be so bad...

Helf the features of The Guild 2, no bank, a more confusing skill system, crafting, PR, family managment and so on...

Do not buy

absolutely loveless game.

Great game！Multiplayer ! The graphics were improved a lot

Still need to enrich game play and simplify operation

Specifically, the warehouse is useless except there is long distance between city and country side. Since there is strict restriction of business building number, the marginal benefit of intermediate storage can not exceed the expected income of extra productive building. Only when the total business building number is over roughly 6 or 7, the benefit of warehouse can be positive.

However, there are limited game play contents after getting knighted.

Don't give up upgrading this game. I am willing to pay DLC for any further enrichment. The framework of the game deserves more investment !!!

good game

Not accessible - no subtitle support on movies

Also all relationship options are het

Amazing game!

Great multiplayer!!!

Buy 2 instead

Alright, I'm Hooked. Also, In slow motion mode (which I love), I was able to clean my bathroom and come back and make my next choice every now and then. Its perfect!

This game plays like your typical abandoned early access game. Some (if not most) game mechanics are completely out of balance, there is almost no sense of actual progression, because most features and buildings that you unlock are next to useless, and most importantly, there's very little challenge. I initially wanted to try it in multiplayer, but after playing a singleplayer campaign i will not even bother. Feels like the developers had a good idea initially, then something went wrong and they gave up halfway and just called it quits and abandoned it.

Great effort. Basically like playing a stable version of Guild 2. Multiplayer works a treat.

Nepotism Simulator

Proper game, no strings attached. just fun and games.

This is the Way!!

Okay and thumbs up because the game is full of good ideas. It's good fun for a while. At some point there is so much going on the game becomes irritating and totally out of control which is a shame (unless you're here for a second job). It's still worth exploring if at a good price. Would be awesome for someone to make this kind of life sim sandbox game but pull it off.

Refund this crap

I like tha game so far.

Don't touch. Unbalanced and shallow. Massive downgrade from Guild 2.

Gaining money and control of council is trivially easy. The main mechanics: production, trade and crime are all trivially simple.

- The simplest production chains are somehow the most profitable.
- A single trade opportunity event can let you increase your wealth 10x with no effort.
- There is literally nothing stopping you from carrying out any crime you want. People walk by as you stab your rivals to deaths and no one cares at all.

Game is shallower than an autoclicker phone game.

changing my review the game is unfinished and they quit 22 hours in and i want my money back who wants to read a half a book

could have been better, took too long to allow mods. 6/10

nice addition to the series

How is the guild 2 better when this games been in development for idk how many years?

It has its moments... honestly, so much wasted potential. The gameplay formula is interestingly unique but not fleshed out. You can only install one mod at a time because coding reasons and you'll probably want to install a mod that will fix market's prices and nerfs the front store. While this is theoretically an endless sandbox game, you won't feel like replaying it after beating it once, as playthroughs are more or less the same.
Buy it for 5€ or less, it doesn't deserve more than that and that's a shame.

I would not recommend it as it is.
Guild 2 is more fun, richer and cheaper. Guild 3 is only a graphics update at this point,
had a crazy complicated history of development and while it is now playable, it's not "amazing".

Definitely better than Guild 2, but although there is much more complexity compared to the original Guild, there is also much more undeveloped potential and the overall experience is less entertaining.
There is some nice medieval architecture, a lot of options to choose from, well set production chains, but almost no chance to rely on productive automatization of work, making the game, in the first place, extremely slow and eventually slower and slower.
Maybe not worth 30 euros but worth try.

Modded it's really good, I would say that it's worth getting this over Guild 2 due to graphics and QOL. The game is a solid 7-8/10.

Juilq